California Fraudulent Transfer Law
California Fraudulent Transfer Law: When a Court Can Undo What You Did
California’s Uniform Voidable Transactions Act lets a creditor unwind a transfer you made to keep property away from it. There are two routes. Actual intent, which courts test against eleven statutory factors, and constructive voidability, which requires no bad intent at all. The outside deadline is seven years. Plan before a claim exists and neither route reaches you.
By Jacob Stein · Last updated August 25, 2026
This is the statute that decides whether asset protection worked. Everything else is drafting. In 2015 the Legislature replaced the old Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act with the Uniform Voidable Transactions Act, Civil Code sections 3439 through 3439.14, which is why you now see courts and lawyers say voidable transaction instead of fraudulent conveyance. The word fraudulent survives in one important place: section 3439.04(a)(1) still turns on actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud.
The practical question clients ask is always the same. Is it too late? The answer depends on what exists on the day you sign, not on how the transfer looks in hindsight. It is also the first thing we test in any piece of lawsuit protection planning. If you want that assessed before you move anything, schedule a consultation.
The two ways a transfer gets undone
The first is actual intent under section 3439.04(a)(1). A transfer is voidable if you made it with actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud any creditor, and this route is available to a creditor whose claim arose before or after the transfer. The burden is on the creditor, by a preponderance of the evidence, under section 3439.04(c).
The second requires no intent. Under section 3439.04(a)(2), a transfer is voidable if you did not receive reasonably equivalent value and you were left with unreasonably small assets or with debts beyond your ability to pay. Section 3439.05 is the closely related test: no reasonably equivalent value plus insolvency, available to a creditor whose claim arose before the transfer. This is where gifts to children and below-market sales to family entities go wrong, and no one has to prove you meant any harm.
The eleven factors, and the one that decides most cases
Section 3439.04(b) lists eleven non-exclusive factors, which courts call badges of fraud. They include whether the transfer was to an insider, whether you kept possession or control, whether it was concealed, whether it was substantially all your assets, whether you were insolvent or became insolvent shortly after, and whether the transfer happened shortly before or after a substantial debt was incurred. There is no scoring formula. As the Court of Appeal put it in Filip v. Bucurenciu, 129 Cal.App.4th 825, 834 (2005), there is no minimum number of factors that must be present before the scales tip in favor of finding actual intent.
Factor four is the one that decides most cases: whether, before the transfer was made, the debtor had been sued or threatened with suit. That single fact is why the date on the deed matters more than the sophistication of the structure. Transfer before there is a claim and the creditor is arguing intent without its best evidence.
How long a creditor has
Section 3439.09 sets three periods, and they are extinguishment provisions rather than ordinary statutes of limitation. For an actual-intent claim, four years after the transfer, or if later, one year after the transfer was or could reasonably have been discovered. For constructive claims under sections 3439.04(a)(2) and 3439.05, four years. And section 3439.09(c) closes the door: notwithstanding any other provision of law, the cause of action is extinguished if no action is brought or levy made within seven years after the transfer.
Bankruptcy changes the math. A trustee gets two years under 11 U.S.C. section 548(a)(1), can reach California’s periods through section 544(b), and gets ten years under section 548(e) for a transfer to a self-settled trust or similar device made with actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud. That last one requires all four elements. Ten years alone proves nothing.
What a court can actually do
Section 3439.07 gives a creditor avoidance of the transfer, attachment, injunction, receivership, and any other relief the circumstances require. Section 3439.08(b)(1) allows a money judgment against the transferee, capped at the lesser of the asset’s value or the amount needed to satisfy the claim. So the person you transferred to is exposed too, which is worth telling your family before you involve them.
The defense is narrower than people assume. Section 3439.08(a) protects a transferee who took in good faith and gave reasonably equivalent value, but only against the actual-intent claim under section 3439.04(a)(1). It is not a defense to the constructive claims, where a good-faith transferee gets only the partial protections in section 3439.08(d). Which is why the sequence of an asset protection plan matters as much as its contents.
Common questions
It is a transfer a court can void under Civil Code section 3439.04 or 3439.05, either because you made it with actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud a creditor, or because you gave away value you could not spare and were left unable to pay your debts. Since 2016 the statute calls it a voidable transaction.
In California, four years from the transfer for an actual-intent claim, or one year from discovery if that is later, with an absolute seven-year cutoff under Civil Code section 3439.09(c). Constructive claims get four years. These are extinguishment periods, so they end the cause of action rather than merely barring the remedy.
Yes, and it is longer in the place that matters. A bankruptcy trustee has two years under 11 U.S.C. section 548(a)(1), can borrow California’s four and seven-year periods through section 544(b), and has ten years to attack a transfer to a self-settled trust under section 548(e) if actual intent is proven.
You can still do useful and lawful things, including restructuring insurance, exemption planning, and negotiating. What you cannot do is move assets away from the claimant and expect it to hold. Once you have been sued or threatened with suit, factor four of section 3439.04(b) is handed to the other side, and a transfer made then is the easiest case a creditor’s lawyer ever gets.
The practical line is the moment a claim exists, and a claim can exist before you know about it. Section 3439.01 defines a claim as a right to payment even if contingent, unmatured, or disputed. The accident happened before the demand letter arrived. That is why real planning is done when nothing is pending.
Either give it back or pay for it. Under section 3439.07 the court can void the transfer, and under section 3439.08(b)(1) it can enter a money judgment against the transferee. A family member who took a house as a gift can end up as a defendant with personal exposure.
It can be. Penal Code section 154 makes it a misdemeanor for a debtor to fraudulently remove property from the state, or to sell, convey, assign, or conceal property with intent to defraud, hinder, or delay creditors. Section 155 covers a person against whom an action is pending or a judgment has been entered. Both carry a felony variant for stock in trade above a low dollar threshold. Prosecutions are rare, but the sections exist.
Yes. In Mejia v. Reed, 31 Cal.4th 657 (2003), the California Supreme Court held that the fraudulent transfer statute applies to marital settlement agreements, so a lopsided property division is not immune because a family court approved it.
Talk to Jacob
If you are trying to work out whether a transfer you already made is exposed, or whether you can still plan, request a consultation.